Publisher delays will affect new comic releases — read our full update.

Auction in progress, bid now! Weekly Auction ends Monday February 3!

Vintage Paper

Below is listed all of the titles in our Vintage Paper department, which encompasses the following categories:

  • Item #61876784
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Front Cover
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Back Cover
    • Paper: Cream to off white
    • Label #4384561018
    • This is a consignment item. A 3% buyer's premium ($50.13) will be charged at checkout.

    Volume 35, Issue 5 - September 1940. Edited by Dorothy McIlwraith. Horror and Fantasy stories in the pulp style. 6.75-in. x 10-in.; 128 newsprint pages, text (with B&W illustrations). Cover price $0.15.

    If you add this item to your want list, we will email you when it becomes available.

    8 MyComicShop users have this issue on their want list.
    2 MyComicShop users have added this issue to their want list within the past six months.

  • Item #61112864
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Front Cover
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Back Cover
    $799.00
    or Best Offer
    • Paper: Off white
    • Label #4418152008
    • This is a consignment item. A 3% buyer's premium ($23.97) will be charged at checkout.

    Make an offer

    You can buy this item by clicking "Add to cart" above and then completing checkout. Or, you may make an offer for this item. Once you make an offer, your offer is valid for 48 hours. The seller may accept your offer, decline your offer, or present you with a counter-offer. If the seller accepts your offer, you are required to purchase the item at the agreed upon price.

    More information about making an offer

    Please create an account or log in to make an offer.



    Volume 35, Issue 5 - September 1940. Edited by Dorothy McIlwraith. Horror and Fantasy stories in the pulp style. 6.75-in. x 10-in.; 128 newsprint pages, text (with B&W illustrations). Cover price $0.15.

    If you add this item to your want list, we will email you when it becomes available.

    8 MyComicShop users have this issue on their want list.
    2 MyComicShop users have added this issue to their want list within the past six months.

  • Item #61841492
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Front Cover
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Back Cover
    $349.00
    or Best Offer
    • Paper: Cream
    • Label #4474815010
    • This is a consignment item. A 3% buyer's premium ($10.47) will be charged at checkout.

    Make an offer

    You can buy this item by clicking "Add to cart" above and then completing checkout. Or, you may make an offer for this item. Once you make an offer, your offer is valid for 48 hours. The seller may accept your offer, decline your offer, or present you with a counter-offer. If the seller accepts your offer, you are required to purchase the item at the agreed upon price.

    More information about making an offer

    Please create an account or log in to make an offer.



    Volume 35, Issue 5 - September 1940. Edited by Dorothy McIlwraith. Horror and Fantasy stories in the pulp style. 6.75-in. x 10-in.; 128 newsprint pages, text (with B&W illustrations). Cover price $0.15.

    If you add this item to your want list, we will email you when it becomes available.

    8 MyComicShop users have this issue on their want list.
    2 MyComicShop users have added this issue to their want list within the past six months.

  • Item #61974848
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Front Cover
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Back Cover
    $199.00
    or Best Offer
    • Paper: Off white
    • Label #4392702005
    • This is a consignment item. A 3% buyer's premium ($5.97) will be charged at checkout.

    Make an offer

    You can buy this item by clicking "Add to cart" above and then completing checkout. Or, you may make an offer for this item. Once you make an offer, your offer is valid for 48 hours. The seller may accept your offer, decline your offer, or present you with a counter-offer. If the seller accepts your offer, you are required to purchase the item at the agreed upon price.

    More information about making an offer

    Please create an account or log in to make an offer.



    Volume 35, Issue 5 - September 1940. Edited by Dorothy McIlwraith. Horror and Fantasy stories in the pulp style. 6.75-in. x 10-in.; 128 newsprint pages, text (with B&W illustrations). Cover price $0.15.

    If you add this item to your want list, we will email you when it becomes available.

    8 MyComicShop users have this issue on their want list.
    2 MyComicShop users have added this issue to their want list within the past six months.

  • Item #61109281
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Front Cover
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Back Cover
    $649.00
    or Best Offer
    • Paper: White
    • Label #4416200003
    • This is a consignment item. A 3% buyer's premium ($19.47) will be charged at checkout.

    Make an offer

    You can buy this item by clicking "Add to cart" above and then completing checkout. Or, you may make an offer for this item. Once you make an offer, your offer is valid for 48 hours. The seller may accept your offer, decline your offer, or present you with a counter-offer. If the seller accepts your offer, you are required to purchase the item at the agreed upon price.

    More information about making an offer

    Please create an account or log in to make an offer.



    Sept 1941. Cover by Margaret Brundage. Horror and supernatural stories by Robert Bloch, Seabury Quinn. Illustrations by Hannes Bok. 6 3/4-in. x 10-in.; black and white; 128 newsprint pages. Cover price $0.15.

    If you add this item to your want list, we will email you when it becomes available.

    4 MyComicShop users have this issue on their want list.
    1 MyComicShop users have added this issue to their want list within the past six months.

  • Item #62132782
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Front Cover
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Back Cover
    $649.00
    or Best Offer
    • Paper: Cream to off white
    • Label #4498304003
    • This is a consignment item. A 3% buyer's premium ($19.47) will be charged at checkout.

    Make an offer

    You can buy this item by clicking "Add to cart" above and then completing checkout. Or, you may make an offer for this item. Once you make an offer, your offer is valid for 48 hours. The seller may accept your offer, decline your offer, or present you with a counter-offer. If the seller accepts your offer, you are required to purchase the item at the agreed upon price.

    More information about making an offer

    Please create an account or log in to make an offer.



    November, 1945. Cover by Lee Brown Coye. Horror and supernatural stories: "Lost Elysium" by Edmond Hamilton, "The Murderous Steam Shovel" by Allison V. Harding, "The Mad Dancers" by Roger S. Vreeland, "Mrs. Lannisfree" by August Derleth, "The Cranberry Goblet" by Harold Lawlor, "The Fangs of Tsan-Lo" by Jim Kjelgaard, "Soul Proprietor" by Robert Bloch, and "The Mirror" by Charles King. Verse: "Midnight Moon" by Stanton A. Coblentz, and "Superstitions and Taboos" by Irwin J. Weill. Softcover Pulp, 6 1/2-in x 10-in, 96 Pages, B&W. Cover price $0.15.

    If you add this item to your want list, we will email you when it becomes available.

    3 MyComicShop users have this issue on their want list.
    0 MyComicShop users have added this issue to their want list within the past six months.

  • Item #61092742
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Front Cover
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Back Cover
    $1,990.00
    or Best Offer
    • Paper: Cream to off white
    • Label #4416090001
    • This is a consignment item. A 3% buyer's premium ($59.70) will be charged at checkout.

    Make an offer

    You can buy this item by clicking "Add to cart" above and then completing checkout. Or, you may make an offer for this item. Once you make an offer, your offer is valid for 48 hours. The seller may accept your offer, decline your offer, or present you with a counter-offer. If the seller accepts your offer, you are required to purchase the item at the agreed upon price.

    More information about making an offer

    Please create an account or log in to make an offer.



    Volume 39, Issue 6 - July, 1946. Cover by Matt Fox. Horror and supernatural stories by Manley Wade Wellman "Shonokin Town", Seabury Quinn, Ray Bradbury "The Night", Allison V. Harding, Jim Kjelgaard, Charles King, Harold Lawlor, E. L. Wright, Stanton Coblentz, and P Schuyler Miller. Illustrations by A. R. Tilburne, Boris Dolgov, Matt Fox, Irwin J. Weill, Lee Brown Coye, and Andrew Brosnatch. 6 3/4-in. x 10-in.; black and white; 100 newsprint pages. Cover price $0.15.

    If you add this item to your want list, we will email you when it becomes available.

    11 MyComicShop users have this issue on their want list.
    2 MyComicShop users have added this issue to their want list within the past six months.

  • Item #61221910
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Front Cover
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Back Cover
    $1,299.00
    or Best Offer
    • Paper: White
    • Label #4426188011
    • This is a consignment item. A 3% buyer's premium ($38.97) will be charged at checkout.

    Make an offer

    You can buy this item by clicking "Add to cart" above and then completing checkout. Or, you may make an offer for this item. Once you make an offer, your offer is valid for 48 hours. The seller may accept your offer, decline your offer, or present you with a counter-offer. If the seller accepts your offer, you are required to purchase the item at the agreed upon price.

    More information about making an offer

    Please create an account or log in to make an offer.



    May 1948. Cover by Matt Fox. Horror and supernatural stories by Allison V. Harding "City of Lost People", Harold Lawlor, C. Hall Thompson, August Derleth "Saunder's Little Friend", Ray Bradbury "Black Ferris", Roger S. Vreeland, Stanton A. Coblentz, Mary Elizabeth Counselman, Peter Phillips, and Davis Grubbs -as (Dave Grubbs) "One Foot in the Grave". Illustrations by John Giunta, Lee Brown Coye, Boris Dolgov, and Fred Humiston. 6 3/4-in. x 10-in.; black and white; 96 newsprint pages. Cover price $0.20.

    If you add this item to your want list, we will email you when it becomes available.

    7 MyComicShop users have this issue on their want list.
    1 MyComicShop users have added this issue to their want list within the past six months.

  • Item #61841481
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Front Cover
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Back Cover
    $749.00
    or Best Offer
    • Paper: White
    • Label #4474815001
    • This is a consignment item. A 3% buyer's premium ($22.47) will be charged at checkout.

    Make an offer

    You can buy this item by clicking "Add to cart" above and then completing checkout. Or, you may make an offer for this item. Once you make an offer, your offer is valid for 48 hours. The seller may accept your offer, decline your offer, or present you with a counter-offer. If the seller accepts your offer, you are required to purchase the item at the agreed upon price.

    More information about making an offer

    Please create an account or log in to make an offer.



    March 1949. Cover by Matt Fox. Horror and supernatural stories by August Derleth "The Testament of Claiborne Boyd", Theodore Sturgeon "The Martian and the Moron", Robert Bloch "The Strange Island of Dr. Nork", Allison V. Harding, Arthur J. Burks, Stanton A. Coblentz, and Thorp McClusky. Illustrations by Fred Humiston, Vincent Napoli, Boris Dolgov, and Lee Brown Coye. 6 3/4-in. x 10-in.; black and white; 96 newsprint pages. Cover price $0.20.

    If you add this item to your want list, we will email you when it becomes available.

    9 MyComicShop users have this issue on their want list.
    0 MyComicShop users have added this issue to their want list within the past six months.

  • Item #61429977
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Front Cover
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Back Cover
    $1,199.00
    or Best Offer
    • Paper: Off white
    • Label #4449592003
    • This is a consignment item. A 3% buyer's premium ($35.97) will be charged at checkout.

    Make an offer

    You can buy this item by clicking "Add to cart" above and then completing checkout. Or, you may make an offer for this item. Once you make an offer, your offer is valid for 48 hours. The seller may accept your offer, decline your offer, or present you with a counter-offer. If the seller accepts your offer, you are required to purchase the item at the agreed upon price.

    More information about making an offer

    Please create an account or log in to make an offer.



    July 1949. Cover by Matt Fox. Horror and supernatural stories by Fredric Brown "Come and Go Mad", Ewen Whyte, H. Russell Wakefield, Stephen Grendon, Russell Branch, Stanton A. Coblentz, Frietz Lieber "In the X-Ray", Harold Lawlor, Robert Bloch "Floral Tribute", and Seabury Quinn. Illustrations by Boris Dolgov, John Giunta, Vincent Napoli, and Matt Fox. 6 3/4-in. x 10-in.; black and white; 96 newsprint pages. Cover price $0.25.

    If you add this item to your want list, we will email you when it becomes available.

    9 MyComicShop users have this issue on their want list.
    2 MyComicShop users have added this issue to their want list within the past six months.

  • Item #61112692
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Front Cover
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Back Cover
    $1,299.00
    or Best Offer
    • Paper: Off white
    • Label #4418152005
    • This is a consignment item. A 3% buyer's premium ($38.97) will be charged at checkout.

    Make an offer

    You can buy this item by clicking "Add to cart" above and then completing checkout. Or, you may make an offer for this item. Once you make an offer, your offer is valid for 48 hours. The seller may accept your offer, decline your offer, or present you with a counter-offer. If the seller accepts your offer, you are required to purchase the item at the agreed upon price.

    More information about making an offer

    Please create an account or log in to make an offer.



    Volume 42, Issue 1 - November, 1949. Cover by Matt Fox. Horror and supernatural stories by Allison V. Harding "The Underbody", Arthur J. Burks, Seabury Quinn, H. Russell Wakefield, Ewen Whyte, August Derleth "Twilight Play", Mary Elizabeth Counselman, Malcolm Kenneth Murchie, Yves Theriault, Emil Petaja, and Malcolm M. Ferguson. Illustrations by Vincent Napoli, lee Brown Coye, Boris Dolgov, and Fred Humiston. 6 3/4-in. x 10-in.; black and white; 100 newsprint pages. Cover price $0.25.

    If you add this item to your want list, we will email you when it becomes available.

    9 MyComicShop users have this issue on their want list.
    0 MyComicShop users have added this issue to their want list within the past six months.

  • Item #61841494
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Front Cover
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Back Cover
    $1,499.00
    or Best Offer
    • Paper: Off white to white
    • Label #4474815012
    • This is a consignment item. A 3% buyer's premium ($44.97) will be charged at checkout.

    Make an offer

    You can buy this item by clicking "Add to cart" above and then completing checkout. Or, you may make an offer for this item. Once you make an offer, your offer is valid for 48 hours. The seller may accept your offer, decline your offer, or present you with a counter-offer. If the seller accepts your offer, you are required to purchase the item at the agreed upon price.

    More information about making an offer

    Please create an account or log in to make an offer.



    July 1950. Cover by Matt Fox. Horror and supernatural stories by Arthur J. Burks "Shallajai", Robert Bloch "The Weird Tailor", Eric Frank Russell, Seabury Quinn, H. Russell Wakefield, Mary Elizabeth Counselman, August Derleth "The Closing Door", Margaret St. Clair, and Cleve Cartmill. Illustrations by Charles A. Kennedy, Vincent Napoli, Matt Fox, Fred Humiston, and John N. Anderson. 6 3/4-in. x 10-in.; black and white; 96 newsprint pages. Cover price $0.25.

    If you add this item to your want list, we will email you when it becomes available.

    4 MyComicShop users have this issue on their want list.
    1 MyComicShop users have added this issue to their want list within the past six months.

  • Item #62193562
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Front Cover
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Back Cover
    • Paper: Off white to white
    • Slab: Significant front/back scuff(s)
    • Label #4421594012
    • This is a consignment item. A 3% buyer's premium ($4.05) will be charged at checkout.

    Vol. 2 #5 - April 1947. Pinup and glamour magazine. Cover by Peter Driben. 8 1/2-in. x 11 1/2-in., 64 pages, sepia tone on newsprint. Cover price $0.25.

    If you add this item to your want list, we will email you when it becomes available.

    3 MyComicShop users have this issue on their want list.
    0 MyComicShop users have added this issue to their want list within the past six months.

  • Item #62272415
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Front Cover
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Back Cover
    • Paper: Off white to white
    • Label #4421594011
    • This is a consignment item. A 3% buyer's premium ($5.25) will be charged at checkout.

    Volume 3, Issue 2 - October, 1947. 8" x 11.5", 68 pages, B&W. Cover price $0.25.

    If you add this item to your want list, we will email you when it becomes available.

    4 MyComicShop users have this issue on their want list.
    0 MyComicShop users have added this issue to their want list within the past six months.

  • Item #62193567
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Front Cover
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Back Cover
    • Paper: Off white to white
    • Label #4421594005
    • This is a consignment item. A 3% buyer's premium ($7.05) will be charged at checkout.

    Volume 6, Issue 1 - August, 1950. Humor and scantily clad women. Peter Driben cover. 8.5" x 11.5". 62 pages. Black and white. Cover price $0.25.

    If you add this item to your want list, we will email you when it becomes available.

    3 MyComicShop users have this issue on their want list.
    0 MyComicShop users have added this issue to their want list within the past six months.

  • Item #62272634
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Front Cover
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Back Cover
    • Paper: Off white to white
    • Label #4421594008
    • This is a consignment item. A 3% buyer's premium ($5.25) will be charged at checkout.

    Bettie Page photo feature in this issue.

    Vol. 10 #2 - October 1954. Men's interest magazine with pin-up and glamour photography. This issue also includes a Bettie Page pictorial of her monkeying around with a gorilla and an Irving Klaw advertisement with a small Betty photo. Peter Driben cover. 8 1/2-in. x 11 1/2-in., 64 pages, B&W. Mature readers. Cover price $0.25.

    If you add this item to your want list, we will email you when it becomes available.

    3 MyComicShop users have this issue on their want list.
    0 MyComicShop users have added this issue to their want list within the past six months.

  • Item #61001089
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Front Cover
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Back Cover
    • Paper: Off white to white
    • Label #4366400010

    One of the most beautiful romance covers ever to appear on a comic book!

    Painted cover by Victor Olson. Stories and art by Everett Raymond Kinstler, Carmine Infantino, Jim Mooney, and Bernard Sachs. An early romance comic from Ziff-Davis that is not like other romance comics. Nora tracks Alan to a Tibetan mountain, where he has fallen in love with the mythical "Snow Woman." The Snow Woman turns out to be a bandit leader who is using Alan as her pawn. Not your typical romance story! Nan and Mal fall in love amid the chaos of the 1906 San Francisco Earthquake. Successful artist Della struggles with selling out. Plus the "true" romance of screen stars Ricardo Montalban and Tallulah Bankhead, with art by Everett Raymond Kinstler! Simple yet stunning painted cover by Victor Olson. Captive of Love; Lets Get Married Tonight; Cops Wife; I Fell for a Killer; My Rival was a Ghost; Heartbreak Sonata; Personality Pointers; Golden Wedding; Secret Kisses; I was a Greenwich Village Character; Ricardo Montalbans Treasured Dream. 32 pages, Full Color. Cover price $0.25.

    If you add this item to your want list, we will email you when it becomes available.

    3 MyComicShop users have this issue on their want list.
    0 MyComicShop users have added this issue to their want list within the past six months.

  • Item #61408364
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Front Cover
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Back Cover
    $599.00
    or Best Offer
    • Paper: Off white to white
    • Label #4448130003
    • This is a consignment item. A 3% buyer's premium ($17.97) will be charged at checkout.

    Make an offer

    You can buy this item by clicking "Add to cart" above and then completing checkout. Or, you may make an offer for this item. Once you make an offer, your offer is valid for 48 hours. The seller may accept your offer, decline your offer, or present you with a counter-offer. If the seller accepts your offer, you are required to purchase the item at the agreed upon price.

    More information about making an offer

    Please create an account or log in to make an offer.



    If you add this item to your want list, we will email you when it becomes available.

    3 MyComicShop users have this issue on their want list.
    0 MyComicShop users have added this issue to their want list within the past six months.

  • Item #61408365
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Front Cover
    Actual item pictured; not a generic image.
    Zoom Back Cover
    $649.00
    or Best Offer
    • Paper: Light tan to off white
    • Label #4448130002
    • This is a consignment item. A 3% buyer's premium ($19.47) will be charged at checkout.

    Make an offer

    You can buy this item by clicking "Add to cart" above and then completing checkout. Or, you may make an offer for this item. Once you make an offer, your offer is valid for 48 hours. The seller may accept your offer, decline your offer, or present you with a counter-offer. If the seller accepts your offer, you are required to purchase the item at the agreed upon price.

    More information about making an offer

    Please create an account or log in to make an offer.



    Volume 4, Issue 5 - October, 1942. 8.5" x 11.5", 120 pages, B&W. Cover price $0.25.

    If you add this item to your want list, we will email you when it becomes available.

    3 MyComicShop users have this issue on their want list.
    0 MyComicShop users have added this issue to their want list within the past six months.