| Issue | #9 |
| Published | April-May 1965 |
| Cover Price | 0.12 |
| Pages | 36 |
| Editing | Richard Hughes |
| Characters | Herbie Popnecker |
| Synopsis | Herbie playing football // Ogden Whitney (signed) |
| Genre | super hero; humor; satire |
| Pencils | Ogden Whitney |
| Inks | Ogden Whitney |
| Characters | Herbie Popnecker; Pincus Popnecker; Mrs. Popnecker; Professor Flipdome |
| Synopsis | Herbie's neighbor, Professor Flipdome, creates the Automatic Imitator, which creates many duplicates of Herbie. Swami O'Toole breaks out of prison and tries to use Herbie's love of lollipops against him, but Herbie's doubles come to the rescue. |
| Genre | super hero; humor; satire |
| Script | Richard Hughes (as Shane O'Shea) |
| Pencils | Ogden Whitney |
| Inks | Ogden Whitney |
| Letters | Ed Hamilton |
| Notes | Story: An O'Shea blue plate special / Art: Whitney ... Real classy like |
| Reprinted | in Herbie #5 (A-plus May 1991) |
| Characters | Herbie Popnecker; Pincus Popnecker; Mrs. Popnecker; Sheriff of Nottingham; Little John; Maid Marian; Robin Hood; Friar Tuck (Herbie look-alike); Satan; Witch |
| Synopsis | Herbie's dad thinks Herbie is a great archer and enters him in the Robin Hood Tournament. Herbie goes back in time to get Robin Hood's bow. |
| Genre | super hero; humor; satire |
| Script | Richard Hughes (as Shane O'Shea) |
| Pencils | Ogden Whitney |
| Inks | Ogden Whitney |
| Letters | Ed Hamilton |
| Notes | Great Plot by Shane O'Shea / Cool Art by Ogden Whitney |