The February Prime Auction has ended! Winners please visit your shopping cart to complete your purchase. Payment due by February 24.

Return Policy

If your order was lost or damaged in transit

Please let us know as soon as possible. We will credit your account with us, refund you, or reship all or part of the order, as appropriate.

If the order was damaged, keep the packaging! We may need it to file for insurance on the package; it may be difficult to refund you if we aren't able to process our claim. You must inform us of any damage to your order within seven business days of receipt.

If you believe we have overgraded a comic

Comics graded by CGC, CBCS, and PGX are not returnable. All other comics may be returned for a refund if we are notified via email (customerservice@mycomicshop.com), or by phone (817-860-7827) within seven days of of receipt. Returns must be received at our office within two weeks of original delivery date (Canadian three weeks, international one month). Basic ground postage will be refunded on any books deemed to have been misgraded.

To receive prompt credit to your mycomicshop.com account or a refund to your credit card, please include a copy of the original invoice with notations for items returned.

Items returned without a copy of the original invoice may experience significant delays in processing. Items returned without authorization may incur a 25% restocking fee, deducted from the value of the refund.

A note on third-party grading

After your order arrives, as we describe above, you will have seven days to evaluate it. If you choose not to return an item to us, the transaction is complete. We will not be able to offer any full or partial credit or refund as a result of any decision made by a third-party grader after the return window has closed.

If we have sent you the wrong book or failed to send a book

Please let us know within seven business days of receipt. We will credit your account, refund you, or ship the proper item, as we deem appropriate. If we need you to return the book, we will reimburse you for basic ground shipping.

If you have purchased a book in error

Please let us know within three business days of receipt. We will refund you for the line-item value of the book (without shipping), less a 25% restocking fee. We will not reimburse you for your shipping.

If you wish to sell a book back to us

If we have sold you a book, it may be returned as above. If you wish to sell us a book back via our buy/trade system, we will consider it a new book and we will buy it as we grade it during check-in. We do not guarantee we will buy it at the same grade we sold it — we guarantee only that once bought, we will sell it as we bought it.

No returns on redeemed digital content

If a publisher includes a redemption key for online content with a comic, we will not accept the item for return if the content has already been redeemed. (Put more plainly, if you peel the sticker off a newly-released comic to reveal the code, we won't accept a return on that item.) Please see our grading terms for more information about digital codes included with books; many books we might sell with the code previously redeemed, and those would be returnable.

We also cannot take responsibility or grant a refund if the publisher chooses not to redeem your code, for whatever reason.